Moissanite
Moss Agate
Emerald
Sapphire
Amethyst
Black Onyx
Opal
Alexandrite
Topaz
Solitaire
Halo
Cluster
Side Stone
Pavé
Split Shank
Art Nouveau
Aquamarine
Blue Sandstone
Moonstone
Black Rutilated Quartz
Lab Diamond
Ruby
Teal Sapphire
Salt & Pepper Diamond
Morganite
Peridot
Garnet – January
Tanzanite – December
Ruby vs. Garnet: Choosing Your Perfect Red Gemstone
0 commentsAt first glance, rubies and garnets appear similar. However, they have distinctly different properties, values, and suitability for various uses. Understanding these differences is not just about identifying a stone, but also about making an informed choice for your next cherished piece of jewelry.
At Pattiring, we believe in empowering you with knowledge. This comprehensive guide will demystify the garnet vs. ruby debate and help you select the perfect red gemstone that aligns with your desires, budget, and lifestyle.
Ruby vs. Garnet: Quick Facts at a Glance
- 1
Garnet vs. Ruby: Color & Composition
While both are undeniably red, the hues and science behind them are different.
Ruby: The king of red, the ruby owes its intense, fiery color to chromium. This element gives rubies their highly saturated red color, which ranges from vibrant pure red to slightly purplish red. The most coveted shade is often referred to as “pigeon’s blood” red: a vivid shade with a slight purple tint and exceptional brilliance.
- Pro tips: One key characteristic that differentiates rubies from other gemstones is their strong fluorescence under ultraviolet (UV) light. This can be a quick indicator of a genuine ruby, though not foolproof.
Garnet: Garnet’s rich red color primarily comes from iron. They typically exhibit a deeper, warmer red with noticeable brownish, purplish, or orange undertones. Unlike rubies, garnets generally do not fluoresce under UV light.
- Pro tips: Note that “garnet” is a group of minerals with similar crystal structures but varying chemical compositions. Common red garnet varieties include pyrope (often purplish red) and almandine (deep red-violet), while rhodolite garnets display beautiful rose-red to purple-red hues.
Garnet vs. Ruby: Hardness & Durability
A gemstone’s hardness directly affects its durability and suitability for everyday wear.
Ruby: With an impressive ranking of 9 on the Mohs scale of mineral hardness, just below diamonds (10), ruby is a hard and durable gemstone. This makes it an ideal choice for jewelry intended for daily wear, including engagement rings and heirloom pieces designed to last for generations. Rubies are highly resistant to scratches and abrasions, maintaining their polish and sparkle over time.
Garnet: Garnets fall within a range of 6.5 to 7.5 on the Mohs scale. While they are still suitable for most jewelry, rubies are softer than other gemstones. This means that they are more susceptible to scratching, chipping, and abrasion from everyday knocks and bumps. This means garnet jewelry requires more care to maintain its pristine condition.
Garnet vs. Ruby: Clarity & Inclusions
A gemstone’s clarity refers to its absence of internal (inclusions) or external (blemishes) flaws.
Ruby: It’s quite common to find inclusions within a natural ruby. These inclusions can appear as fine, needle-like structures known as “silk” (rutile needles) or as tiny crystals and color zoning. These inclusions often serve as fingerprints, providing evidence of a ruby’s natural origin. In some cases, they can enhance a ruby’s beauty by diffusing light. Most rubies on the market today undergo heat treatment to improve their color and clarity. This is a widely accepted practice in the gem industry.
Garnet: Most red garnets are eye-clean, meaning they have no visible inclusions to the naked eye. This makes them appear very clear and brilliant. Unlike rubies, garnets are rarely treated to enhance their color or clarity, and are often 100% natural. A notable exception is the rare green demantoid garnet, which can contain distinctive “horsetail” inclusions that are highly prized and can increase its value.
Garnet vs. Ruby: Rarity, Size & Value
The availability and size of a gemstone significantly impact its price.
Ruby: Fine-quality rubies weighing more than one carat are exceptionally rare, contributing to their high value. The price per carat for a ruby increases exponentially with size. Large, high-quality rubies are some of the most expensive colored gemstones in the world. Their historical prestige and rarity also make them potential investments and coveted heirloom pieces.
Garnet: Garnets are much more abundant in nature. Large, eye-clean specimens are relatively common and affordable. Their value does not increase as dramatically with carat weight as rubies do, making large garnet pieces much more affordable. This makes garnet an excellent choice if you want a substantial red gemstone without a high price tag.
Garnet vs. Ruby: Origins & History
Ruby: Known as the “King of Gems” since ancient times, rubies have been traded along the North Silk Road since 200 BC. Ancient Hindus called them “ratnaraj,” meaning “King of Gems,” and they symbolize love, courage, passion, and mystical protection. Major historical and current mining locations include Myanmar (Burma), which is known for its “pigeon’s blood” rubies, as well as Mozambique, Thailand, and Sri Lanka.
Garnet: Garnets can be traced back to ancient Egypt and Rome, where they were often buried with mummies or used in signet rings to seal important documents. The name “garnet” comes from the Latin “granatus,” meaning “seed-like,” about its resemblance to pomegranate seeds. Garnets have been found worldwide, with significant deposits in India, Sri Lanka, Madagascar, and the United States. Garnet symbolizes loyalty and love, and is the traditional gemstone for the 2nd wedding anniversary.
Garnet vs. Ruby: Birthstone & Astrological Connections
Both garnet and ruby hold special significance as birthstones and zodiac gems.
Garnet: Garnet is the traditional January birthstone. Its deep red hues evoke warmth and vitality, making it a fitting gemstone for the beginning of a new year. Although garnet is primarily associated with January, it is most commonly linked to the zodiac sign of Capricorn (December 22-January 19). Some sources also connect it with Aquarius (January 20-February 18).
Ruby: Ruby is the vibrant July birthstone. Its fiery red color symbolizes love, passion, and energy, encapsulating the spirit of summer perfectly. It is primarily associated with the zodiac sign Cancer (June 21-July 22). Its passionate energy and protective qualities resonate with Cancer’s nurturing and emotional depth. Some sources also associate it with the zodiac sign Leo (July 23-August 22).
Ruby vs. Garnet: Which Red Is Right for You?
The best red gemstone ultimately depends on your preferences, budget, and intended use.
Choose a Ruby if:
- You want a highly durable gemstone for everyday wear, especially for an engagement ring or other heirloom pieces.
- You are drawn to its iconic, intense, fiery red color and unique inner glow.
- You are looking for a valuable gemstone with investment potential.
- You want to celebrate a July birthday or a significant milestone.
- You prefer a gemstone associated with luxury, passion, and power. Rubies pair exquisitely with yellow gold, enhancing their classic, rich appeal.
Choose a Garnet if:
- You want a stunning red gemstone that is more budget-friendly and allows for larger carat sizes.
- You prefer a deeper, warmer red hue ranging from fiery to subdued.
- You want a versatile gemstone that looks beautiful in various jewelry settings and with different metals, including white gold, platinum, and yellow gold.
- You are celebrating a January birthday or a 2nd wedding anniversary.
- You want a gemstone that is typically untreated and eye-clean. Garnets are also an excellent choice for unique, custom-cut pieces, such as antique-inspired intaglios.
Conclusion: Ruby vs. Garnet
Both rubies and garnets are magnificent red gemstones with distinct characteristics and charm. Rubies symbolize luxury and enduring strength, offering unparalleled fiery brilliance and hardness. Garnets, on the other hand, are exceptionally accessible and offer a rich spectrum of deep reds and remarkable clarity, making them a versatile and beautiful choice for any occasion.
Ready to find your perfect red gemstone? Explore Pattiring’s exquisite Ruby Jewelry and Garnet Jewelry collections today, or connect with our gemology experts for personalized advice!
FAQ
Determining the difference between a ruby and a garnet involves examining several key characteristics. Rubies typically have a vivid, pure red to purplish-red hue, and they are significantly harder than garnets (Mohs 9 vs. 6.5-7.5). Many rubies also fluoresce bright red under UV light, a trait rarely seen in garnets. Lastly, rubies are considerably more expensive and often have a more intense sparkle compared to the typically warmer glow of a garnet.
The value of garnets varies significantly by type and quality. Generally, most red garnets range from $10 to $500 per carat. Rare varieties, such as demantoid or tsavorite garnets, can command much higher prices, ranging from $1,000 to over $7,000 per carat, especially for cleaner, larger stones.
Prices also vary widely based on the 4 Cs (color, clarity, cut, and carat weight) and origin. They can range from a few hundred dollars per carat to over $100,000 per carat for exceptional, high-quality, unheated stones, such as “pigeon’s blood” red Burmese rubies. Even smaller, high-quality rubies often start at $1,000 per carat.
Garnets are typically deep red gemstones with warm, rich hues that can have brownish, purplish, or orange undertones, resembling pomegranate seeds. While red is the most common color, garnets occur in nearly every color, including green, orange, yellow, and even rare blues. They usually have a soft, vitreous luster and can be very clear or contain minor inclusions.
